All-Star Game — July 10, 1951
AL Roster
25 players
| Pos | Player | Team | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | Ned Garver | St. Louis Browns | Yes |
| C | Yogi Berra HOF | New York Yankees | Yes |
| 1B | Ferris Fain | Philadelphia Athletics | Yes |
| 2B | Nellie Fox HOF | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| 3B | George Kell HOF | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| SS | Chico Carrasquel | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| LF | Ted Williams HOF | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
| CF | Dom DiMaggio | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
| RF | Vic Wertz | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| — | Bob Lemon HOF | Cleveland Indians | Yes |
| — | Bobby Doerr HOF | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
| — | Bobby Shantz | Philadelphia Athletics | — |
| — | Connie Marrero | Washington Senators | — |
| — | Eddie Lopat | New York Yankees | Yes |
| — | Eddie Robinson | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| — | Fred Hutchinson | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| — | Jim Busby | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| — | Jim Hegan | Cleveland Indians | Yes |
| — | Joe DiMaggio HOF | New York Yankees | — |
| — | Larry Doby HOF | Cleveland Indians | Yes |
| — | Mel Parnell | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
| — | Minnie Miñoso HOF | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| — | Phil Rizzuto HOF | New York Yankees | Yes |
| — | Randy Gumpert | Chicago White Sox | — |
| — | Vern Stephens | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
NL Roster
25 players
| Pos | Player | Team | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | Robin Roberts HOF | Philadelphia Phillies | Yes |
| C | Roy Campanella HOF | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| 1B | Gil Hodges HOF | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| 2B | Jackie Robinson HOF | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| 3B | Bob Elliott | Boston Braves | Yes |
| SS | Al Dark | New York Giants | Yes |
| LF | Stan Musial HOF | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| CF | Richie Ashburn HOF | Philadelphia Phillies | Yes |
| RF | Del Ennis | Philadelphia Phillies | Yes |
| — | Bruce Edwards | Chicago Cubs | — |
| — | Don Newcombe | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| — | Duke Snider HOF | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| — | Dutch Leonard | Chicago Cubs | — |
| — | Enos Slaughter HOF | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| — | Ewell Blackwell | Cincinnati Reds | Yes |
| — | Johnny Wyrostek | Cincinnati Reds | Yes |
| — | Larry Jansen | New York Giants | — |
| — | Pee Wee Reese HOF | Brooklyn Dodgers | Yes |
| — | Preacher Roe | Brooklyn Dodgers | — |
| — | Ralph Kiner HOF | Pittsburgh Pirates | Yes |
| — | Red Schoendienst HOF | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| — | Sal Maglie | New York Giants | Yes |
| — | Wally Westlake | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| — | Warren Spahn HOF | Boston Braves | — |
| — | Willie Jones | Philadelphia Phillies | Yes |