Two All-Star Games were played each season from 1959 through 1962. Players selected for
both games count a single All-Star season.
All-Star Game — Game 1 — July 11, 1961
AL Roster
25 players
| Pos | Player | Team | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | Whitey Ford HOF | New York Yankees | Yes |
| C | John Romano | Cleveland Indians | Yes |
| 1B | Norm Cash | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| 2B | Johnny Temple | Cleveland Indians | Yes |
| 3B | Brooks Robinson HOF | Baltimore Orioles | Yes |
| SS | Tony Kubek | New York Yankees | Yes |
| LF | Rocky Colavito | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| CF | Mickey Mantle HOF | New York Yankees | Yes |
| RF | Roger Maris | New York Yankees | Yes |
| — | Al Kaline HOF | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| — | Billy Pierce | Chicago White Sox | — |
| — | Dick Donovan | Washington Senators | Yes |
| — | Dick Howser | Kansas City Athletics | Yes |
| — | Elston Howard | New York Yankees | Yes |
| — | Frank Lary | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| — | Harmon Killebrew HOF | Minnesota Twins | Yes |
| — | Hoyt Wilhelm HOF | Baltimore Orioles | Yes |
| — | Jackie Brandt | Baltimore Orioles | Yes |
| — | Jim Bunning HOF | Detroit Tigers | Yes |
| — | Jim Gentile | Baltimore Orioles | Yes |
| — | Jim Perry | Cleveland Indians | — |
| — | Mike Fornieles | Boston Red Sox | Yes |
| — | Nellie Fox HOF | Chicago White Sox | Yes |
| — | Ryne Duren | Los Angeles Angels | — |
| — | Yogi Berra HOF | New York Yankees | Yes |
NL Roster
25 players
| Pos | Player | Team | Played |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | Warren Spahn HOF | Milwaukee Braves | Yes |
| C | Smoky Burgess | Pittsburgh Pirates | Yes |
| 1B | Bill White | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| 2B | Frank Bolling | Milwaukee Braves | Yes |
| 3B | Eddie Mathews HOF | Milwaukee Braves | Yes |
| SS | Maury Wills | Los Angeles Dodgers | Yes |
| LF | Orlando Cepeda HOF | San Francisco Giants | Yes |
| CF | Willie Mays HOF | San Francisco Giants | Yes |
| RF | Roberto Clemente HOF | Pittsburgh Pirates | Yes |
| — | Art Mahaffey | Philadelphia Phillies | — |
| — | Bob Purkey | Cincinnati Reds | Yes |
| — | Dick Stuart | Pittsburgh Pirates | Yes |
| — | Don Zimmer | Chicago Cubs | Yes |
| — | Eddie Kasko | Cincinnati Reds | — |
| — | Frank Robinson HOF | Cincinnati Reds | Yes |
| — | George Altman | Chicago Cubs | Yes |
| — | Hank Aaron HOF | Milwaukee Braves | Yes |
| — | Joey Jay | Cincinnati Reds | — |
| — | John Roseboro | Los Angeles Dodgers | — |
| — | Ken Boyer | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| — | Mike McCormick | San Francisco Giants | Yes |
| — | Roy Face | Pittsburgh Pirates | Yes |
| — | Sandy Koufax HOF | Los Angeles Dodgers | Yes |
| — | Stan Musial HOF | St. Louis Cardinals | Yes |
| — | Stu Miller | San Francisco Giants | Yes |
All-Star Game — Game 2 — July 31, 1961
AL Roster
29 players
NL Roster
28 players